Back
Physical Security Industry

Thermal vs Night Vision vs Infrared - Which One is Right for You?

Stu Waters
Dec 9, 2024

When it comes to surveillance, low light or no light conditions can make it difficult to identify potential threats that can pose security concerns. This is where advanced vision technologies come into use. Cameras equipped with these technologies can spot intruders and suspicious activities even in near-darkness environments.

In that context, thermal, night vision and infrared cameras are the most ideal options you can choose from. However, it's necessary to understand the differences between these technologies to make the right decision based on your needs. 

This article goes over thermal vs night vision comparison and how they differ from infrared to help you choose the right option for your security or surveillance. 

What is Thermal Imaging?

Thermal imaging uses infrared technology to identify emerging heat from an object. Because of this, thermal imaging is highly effective even in low-light or nighttime environments where a normal camera may struggle to capture clear visuals. This makes it easy to detect temperature differences even through obstacles like smoke or fog. Additionally, it also helps in: 

  • Identifying temperature anomalies that can signal overheating equipment or a potential fire hazard. 
  • Allowing for safe inspections without any physical contact. 
  • Identifying areas of heat loss or inefficiencies in the premises. 
  • Monitoring machinery and equipment for unexpected downtime and costly

Since thermal imaging offers so many advantages, it is widely applicable in industries like manufacturing, construction, public safety, health care, wildlife agriculture, etc.

What is Night Vision?

Night vision is a technology specifically designed to improve visibility in nighttime conditions, mainly by amplifying ambient light. It works by collecting the minimal light available and intensifying it to create a visible image with specialized sensors and lenses with image intensification technology.

To make it work, the device captures faint light from the environment and converts it into electrons. These electrons are amplified and projected on a phosphor screen, which creates a bright and clear image even in (almost) total darkness. However, some night vision systems also come with infrared eliminators to provide additional light if ambient light is insufficient. 

What is Infrared?

Infrared is basically centered around detecting and interpreting electromagnetic waves just beyond the visible light spectrum. These waves are emitted naturally by objects in the form of heat energy, making infrared technology a reliable method to perceive environments that are otherwise hidden from the human eye.

Systems that use this technology are quite versatile and come in different types, each suited to specific applications like: 

  • Near-infrared: It operates at a shorter wavelength and is often used in communication and optical devices.
  • Mid-infrared: It is primarily used for heat sensing.
  • Far infrared: It specializes in detecting significant thermal emissions.

Infrared cameras take these capabilities further by converting thermal radiation into visible images. This offers several advantages like:

  • Ensuring accuracy in challenging conditions with visibility-reducing factors. 
  • Helping with inspections from a distance to ensure safety in hazardous environments.
  • Detecting issues like heat leaks or mechanical problems without physical assessment.

Thermal vs Night Vision vs Infrared

Thermal, night vision and infrared are critical vision technologies that have made modern security camera solutions much more effective than traditional options. However, there are several differences in their functionalities, available features, and other aspects that decide the applicable use cases. Here are several considerations to note:

Technology 

Thermal imaging works by detecting heat signatures released by objects to measure temperature variations and visually represent the heat distribution. This is quite different from invisible light, where thermal sensors capture the invisible heat spectrum, making it a preferred choice for detecting hidden objects in adverse conditions.

Night vision on the other hand amplifies ambient light, including both visible and near-infrared light to make objects visible in low light. This works when image intensifier tubes enhance the available light to produce clear and brighter images. However, it depends on some level of light to function effectively. This may include moonlight or artificial sources, whichever is available.

Infrared technology bridges the gap between the two as it offers active and passive modes. Active infrared uses an infrared light source to illuminate the scene while passive infrared (often grouped with thermal imaging) detects naturally emitted radiation, allowing for visibility even in total darkness. This capability makes it suitable for both low-light enhancement and thermal detection.

Range and Visibility 

Thermal imaging is far superior for long-range detection and is often used to identify heat-emitting objects. It can penetrate environmental barriers, which makes it indispensable for applications like military operations, firefighting, and wildlife tracking. Since thermal devices focus on heat signatures rather than visible light, they work effectively in extreme visibility conditions. 

Night vision works best in a close-to-mid-range environment where at least some ambient light is present. However, due to its dependence on light, it is less effective in pitch-black environments or through obstructions. That's why it is more appropriate for tactical missions, security, and other outdoor activities.

Infrared technology varies depending on its mode. Active infrared provides short-range visibility while passive infrared supports long-range implications and can detect objects in complete darkness. However, environmental sectors such as extreme ambient heat or reflective services may interfere with its performance in certain scenarios.

Image Quality and Resolution 

Thermal imaging gives grayscale or false color images that prioritize heat differentiation over fine details. So while they are excellent for identifying temperature variations, the resolution is generally lower than that of night vision or advanced infrared systems. 

Night vision produces higher-resolution images with natural colors, making it ideal for tasks that need detailed visuals such as identifying individuals or objects. The clarity depends on the quality of the device and the amount of ambient light available. However, advanced generations offer significant improvements in image quality, often surpassing thermal imaging and infrared. 

Infrared imaging often provides visuals – quite similar to thermal imaging but is typically less detailed than night vision. While active infrared systems can produce sharper images in short-range applications, passive infrared systems prioritize functional visibility over image quality. This makes the infrared technology ideal for detecting heat anomalies.  

Power Requirements 

Thermal imaging devices usually need more power due to their dependence on complex thermal sensors and image processing units. These systems need to continuously detect, interpret, and display temperature variations, which requires higher energy consumption than other technologies. 

Night vision devices are relatively energy-efficient – especially the new year generations with optimized circuitry and lightweight materials. Since they amplify existing light rather than generating heat-based visuals, their power consumption stays moderate. They can often function for hours, making them an ideal choice for handheld or portable applications.

Infrared technology varies in its power requirements depending on its mode. Active infrared consumes more power due to the constant emission of infrared light while passive infrared systems operate similarly to thermal imaging. However, the choice of infrared application impacts power efficiency whereas active infrared is more suitable for short-term use.

Price

Thermal imaging devices are comparatively more expensive due to the complexity of their sensors and the ability to detect heat signatures accurately. Night vision equipment is generally more affordable and accessible, especially grade-level consumer-grade devices. Their balance of functionality and cost-effectiveness helps in catering to diverse use cases.

Infrared systems, on the other hand, offer a wide price range depending on the application. Active IR cameras, which are often used in CCTV setups, are relatively cost-effective. Passive IR systems that overlap with thermal imaging usually tend to be more costly due to their advanced capabilities. However, the affordability of infrared systems makes them more versatile across different industries.

Thermal vs Infrared Camera

Let's take a look at the key differences between thermal cameras and infrared cameras based on several criteria.

Best Security Camera System with Night Vision

Night vision capability enables security camera systems to work efficiently even in low light conditions, ensuring round-the-clock security of your premises. Coram offers seamless integration with your existing camera infrastructure to support nighttime monitoring without any extra lighting. This way, you get consistent visibility and comprehensive coverage at all times.

Coram's Advanced Monitoring for 24/7 Security

Round-the-clock security demands advanced monitoring that goes beyond basic surveillance. Coram offers smart functionalities that use advanced technologies to ensure your premises are safe and secure at all times.

Light Hunter Technology 

Coram's cameras use light hunter technology with low-light sensors to capture detailed footage. This provides clear visibility even in near darkness where standard cameras fail to deliver the same quality. 

Light hunter technology works great for areas with minimal light helping with accurate detection and tracking events like trespassing or line crossing. Hence, it helps security teams monitor sensitive areas 24/7 and ensure optimum safety irrespective of lighting conditions. 

Color Hunter Technology 

Coram's color hunter cameras capture full-colour footage and identify key details like vehicle types, colors, and specific objects. With the available color context, the security camera system can identify unauthorized individuals and detect loitering or specific vehicles. This can help you improve situational awareness and empower your security teams to respond with in-depth details. 

FAQs

What is the main difference between thermal and infrared?

The main difference between thermal and infrared is that thermal can detect infrared emissions and then convert them to thermal images. 

Can night vision work in total darkness?

No, it cannot work in total darkness because the device would need at least some light to magnify and create an image with it. 

Which technology is best for outdoor surveillance?

Thermal technology works best for outdoor surveillance compared to night vision or infrared due to its capability of detecting heat signatures even in low light. 

Conclusion

Choosing the right technology and camera to address your surveillance needs, even in low light conditions is a critical decision that can leave critical areas in your property unmonitored. To ensure effective surveillance, here are the differences between thermal night vision and infrared that need to be considered:

  • Thermal imaging works best to detect heat signatures in toddler darkness or the presence of environmental barriers. 
  • Night vision offers detailed visuals and is perfect for practical missions or security monitoring to identify individuals or objects. 
  • Infrared is quite versatile as it can offer short-range visibility (active infrared) as well as long-range thermal detection (passive mode).

Understanding the differences between these technologies can help you select the most effective solution. So, evaluate your needs well and choose the technology that provides the most effective and reliable security solution based on your unique needs.

Find Best Security Camera for Your Business
Looking for expert advice on business security? Try Coram AI with a free, no-commitment demo and see how it fits your needs.

Frequently Asked Questions

No items found.

Get a personalized quote and see Coram AI in action with real cameras

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

Get Your 3-Minute Demo Video Now!

Discover Coram AI's unmatched cloud camera security: seamlessly scalable, tailored for your business, delivering immediate and lasting value.

Thank you!
Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.